← All writing

ARTICLE 63·MULTILATERAL DIPLOMACY AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE

Voice of the Global South 2024 and India’s Development Compact Proposal

India’s third Voice of Global South Summit, held virtually on 17 August 2024, returned to a question that the G20 year had left open: how can international cooperation respond to countries’ development priorities without imposing a single model? Prime Minister…

Original editorial illustration for article 63: Voice of the Global South 2024 and India’s Development Compact Proposal.
Original editorial illustration by Ibrahim Javaid. Conceptual scene, not to scale.

INTERACTIVE 3D EXPLAINERMultilateral diplomacy and global governance

A closer look at the argument.

Open each layer to move from the article’s question, through its evidence, to the conclusion and limits.

01The question

India’s third Voice of Global South Summit, held virtually on 17 August 2024, returned to a question that the G20 year had left open: how can international cooperation respond to countries’ development priorities without imposing a single model? Prime Minister Narendra Modi used the summit to propose a Global Development Compact based on trade for development…

Read the article and sources
02The record

The summit brought leaders and ministers together across sessions on trade, health, energy, finance, education and the environment. India presented the compact as a way to carry forward the development agenda after its G20 presidency. Its emphasis on consultation and national ownership is consistent with the stated principles of India’s development partnerships, which are…

Read the article and sources
03What follows

The Global Development Compact can provide a useful frame for cooperation if it remains practical and open to partner priorities. Its credibility will come from detailed agreements, transparent financing, local capacity and independently observable results. The August 2024 summit established a political starting point. It did not settle the compact’s operating rules, funding…

Read the article and sources

India’s third Voice of Global South Summit, held virtually on 17 August 2024, returned to a question that the G20 year had left open: how can international cooperation respond to countries’ development priorities without imposing a single model? Prime Minister Narendra Modi used the summit to propose a Global Development Compact based on trade for development, capacity-building, technology sharing, project-specific concessional finance and grants. The proposal was a political framework for discussion, not a signed treaty or a funded programme with universal terms.

The summit brought leaders and ministers together across sessions on trade, health, energy, finance, education and the environment. India presented the compact as a way to carry forward the development agenda after its G20 presidency. Its emphasis on consultation and national ownership is consistent with the stated principles of India’s development partnerships, which are framed as demand-driven and respectful of partner-country priorities. The next step is to translate those principles into projects with clear budgets, timelines, local participation and public reporting. (MEA country brief recording the 3rd summit; MEA overview of India’s development partnership)

The compact’s proposed elements address different barriers. Trade can help firms reach markets, but market access is valuable only when countries have productive capacity and infrastructure. Training can build skills, but skills initiatives need local employers and institutions. Technology sharing can support public services and industry, but it requires adaptation, maintenance and appropriate protections for data and intellectual property. Concessional finance and grants can fund projects that do not attract private capital, but sound debt assessments and transparent procurement remain essential.

India has experience with several instruments that could inform such cooperation, including the Indian Technical and Economic Cooperation programme, lines of credit, scholarships, digital public infrastructure partnerships and disaster assistance. Those instruments are not interchangeable, and their effects vary by partner and project. A compact should establish ways to assess local demand, select appropriate tools and measure outcomes over time. A catalogue of offers would not be enough.

The proposal also faces a broader test of trust. Developing countries have reason to scrutinize whether finance creates debt burdens, whether technology is accessible and whether suppliers remain available after project launch. A compact that promises respect for sovereignty must make recipient governments and communities participants in design and evaluation. Indian programmes should be assessed by delivery, maintenance and public benefit, alongside the diplomatic value India derives from them.

To make the compact operational, India and partner governments would need a simple project cycle. A country should identify a need through its own institutions, agree on the financing instrument and implementation partner, publish the expected costs and risks, then review the results with local stakeholders. This sequence helps distinguish a partnership from a catalogue of offers. It also lets governments compare a grant, a concessional loan, commercial finance or technical support before committing. A public register of compact projects could list responsibilities, delivery dates, local procurement and maintenance plans, so that partners can see whether commitments translate into services or productive capacity.

The proposal should also make room for disagreement and learning. A partner may reject a project, prefer another supplier or decide that domestic investment is more suitable. Respecting those choices would demonstrate that sovereignty is more than a phrase. India can still pursue its commercial interests, but should disclose when its firms are expected to benefit and how procurement is handled. Evaluations should include unsuccessful projects and unintended consequences. A development framework that reports only completed outputs risks overstating impact; one that publishes lessons can build trust and improve the next round of cooperation.

The compact would benefit from a clear way to handle trade-offs among its elements. A country may prefer a grant for training, a loan for transport infrastructure or technical advice for reforming standards. A standard package could be inappropriate if it ignores fiscal capacity or local institutions. India can offer choices and make the cost and conditions of each option legible. Partner governments should be able to combine or decline instruments, and should have a voice in selecting implementing agencies. These practices would turn national ownership into an observable process.

Accountability should recognize that development outcomes take time and are affected by conditions beyond the project. A road may be completed but see limited use because regional trade routes change; a training programme may need several years to affect local capacity. Evaluations should set a baseline, track outputs and examine longer-term benefits without attributing every change to the compact. Independent review can identify unintended consequences and show when a project should be modified. Publishing both positive results and limitations would give the proposal greater credibility with participants.

The Global Development Compact can provide a useful frame for cooperation if it remains practical and open to partner priorities. Its credibility will come from detailed agreements, transparent financing, local capacity and independently observable results. The August 2024 summit established a political starting point. It did not settle the compact’s operating rules, funding scale or governance. India can strengthen its proposal by moving from broad principles to a small set of demonstrable partnerships and then sharing what worked and what did not.

Sources