← All writing

ARTICLE 42·NEIGHBOURHOOD DIPLOMACY

Jammu and Kashmir’s 2024 Assembly Election and Democratic Representation

Ibrahim Javaid

Original editorial illustration for article 42: Jammu and Kashmir’s 2024 Assembly Election and Democratic Representation.
Original editorial illustration by Ibrahim Javaid. Conceptual scene, not to scale.

INTERACTIVE EXPLAINERNeighbourhood diplomacy

A closer look at the argument.

Open each layer to move from the article’s question, through its evidence, to the conclusion and limits.

01The question
02The record

Status checked: 17 November 2026

Read the article and sources
03What follows

The appropriate conclusion is therefore supportive, but measured. Holding the election gave people a representative institution and a lawful path to contest policy. Its turnout, candidate participation, and practical conduct are meaningful indicators of participation, as documented by the Election Commission. They do not establish unanimity, erase the limits of Union…

Read the article and sources

Ibrahim Javaid

Status checked: 17 November 2026

The 2024 Jammu and Kashmir Assembly election restored an elected legislature after a decade without an Assembly poll. Its importance lies in the institution it reactivated: voters could choose representatives, contest government decisions through parties, and send local priorities into a public forum. The vote strengthened democratic representation within the constitutional framework then in force. It did not settle every question about that framework, restore statehood, or serve as a referendum on the 2019 changes.

The distinction matters. India can defend the decision to conduct the election as a practical democratic step while acknowledging that representative government in a Union Territory has a different scope from a state government. Participation is real, but so are the limits placed on the elected Assembly. A fair assessment should recognize both.

From constitutional judgment to the ballot

The 2019 Reorganisation Act created Jammu and Kashmir as a Union Territory with an Assembly and Ladakh as a separate Union Territory. After the Supreme Court’s December 2023 Article 370 judgment, the Election Commission held three-phase polls on 18 and 25 September and 1 October 2024; results were published on 8 October. The Court had directed elections by 30 September and called for statehood restoration “at the earliest and as soon as possible.” Polling concluded one day after the date it set. Supreme Court of India, In Re: Article 370, 11 December 2023; Election Commission, polling conclusion, 1 October 2024; Election Commission, official results portal.

The Commission reported turnout of 63.88 per cent at polling stations, compared with 58.58 per cent in the 2024 Lok Sabha election. Those different elections are not interchangeable measures of political opinion. Women’s turnout was 63.04 per cent overall and 70.02 per cent in the third phase, compared with 64.68 per cent for men overall and 69.37 per cent in that phase. The figures show meaningful participation, not a shared view on autonomy, security, economic policy, or the 2019 constitutional changes. Election Commission of India, final turnout press note, 3 October 2024.

The Election Commission reported no repolls, webcasting at polling stations across the 90 constituencies, and an increase in women candidates from 28 in 2014 to 43 in 2024. It also described campaigning as vibrant across the political spectrum. These are official administration records, not proof that every political or civil-liberties concern had been resolved. Election Commission, polling conclusion, 1 October 2024.

What representation offers

An Assembly gives citizens a regular channel to raise questions about public services, local development, budgets, and laws within the legislature’s jurisdiction. It also creates a visible arena for disagreement. Parties that oppose the Union government’s position can compete for seats and seek support from voters. This is a strength of India’s constitutional system: disputes over policy can be expressed through campaigns, debate, legislative votes, and the next election, rather than being confined to street pressure or security confrontation.

The 2024 election used a revised constituency map. The 90-seat Assembly includes nine seats reserved for Scheduled Tribes and seven for Scheduled Castes; the Commission described the ST reservation as a first for the Assembly. Reservation creates a formal route for representation, though it cannot guarantee that communities’ interests will be met. The Commission also reported dedicated migrant polling stations and home voting for eligible elderly and disabled electors. Election Commission, delimitation order and constituency structure; Election Commission, polling conclusion, 1 October 2024.

This is a defensible basis for supporting the decision to hold the poll. Elections do not remove every grievance before they begin; they let citizens select representatives while those grievances remain contested. The vote cannot be claimed as endorsement of the government’s 2019 constitutional choices. In fact, the legitimacy of an election depends on allowing voters to select parties and candidates who criticize those choices. That openness makes the result politically meaningful without pretending that one ballot answers every constitutional question.

The limits voters still face

The Assembly’s authority is narrower than that of a state legislature. Section 32 of the Reorganisation Act allows it to legislate on many subjects in the State List and Concurrent List, but excludes “public order” and “police.” The Act also establishes the Lieutenant Governor as the Union-appointed administrator. As of 17 November 2026, the Ministry of Home Affairs continues to list Jammu and Kashmir as a Union Territory with a legislature, while the Election Commission lists the current Assembly’s term as 4 November 2024 to 3 November 2029. Statehood has not been restored. Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019, sections 13 and 32, India Code; Ministry of Home Affairs, J&K and Ladakh Affairs Division; Election Commission, terms of the Houses.

That limited authority is the strongest counterpoint to treating the election as the completion of democratic restoration. Critics of the 2019 reorganisation argue that the loss of statehood reduced local control and that a Union Territory Assembly cannot exercise the same powers as the former state legislature. Those arguments deserve to be debated directly. The Supreme Court upheld the main Article 370 outcome but did not decide whether Parliament can convert an entire state into Union Territories; it relied on the Union’s assurance that statehood would be restored and called for restoration as soon as possible. An election cannot substitute for that unresolved federal question.

The appropriate conclusion is therefore supportive, but measured. Holding the election gave people a representative institution and a lawful path to contest policy. Its turnout, candidate participation, and practical conduct are meaningful indicators of participation, as documented by the Election Commission. They do not establish unanimity, erase the limits of Union Territory status, or settle the demand for statehood. India’s case for constitutional integration is more persuasive when electoral accountability continues alongside a credible path to fuller representative government. Sustaining democratic confidence now requires the Assembly to function, the elected government to be heard within its powers, and the Union to address the statehood commitment through constitutional means.

Sources