← All writing

ARTICLE 41·DEFENCE AND CONSTITUTIONAL DECISIONS

The Supreme Court’s 2023 Article 370 Judgment and Constitutional Process

Ibrahim Javaid

Original editorial illustration for article 41: The Supreme Court’s 2023 Article 370 Judgment and Constitutional Process.
Original editorial illustration by Ibrahim Javaid. Conceptual scene, not to scale.

INTERACTIVE EXPLAINERDefence and constitutional decisions

A closer look at the argument.

Open each layer to move from the article’s question, through its evidence, to the conclusion and limits.

01The question
02The record

Status checked: 17 November 2026

Read the article and sources
03What follows

For India, the ruling establishes that constitutional integration can proceed through the mechanisms the Court found valid. For Jammu and Kashmir’s people, the task now includes accountable government, the protection of rights, and credible progress on the promised restoration of statehood. These obligations are not legal footnotes to the judgment. They are part of what will…

Read the article and sources

Ibrahim Javaid

Status checked: 17 November 2026

The Supreme Court’s judgment of 11 December 2023 did more than endorse the Union government’s 2019 decision on Article 370. It examined how the President and Parliament had used constitutional powers, upheld the main outcome, and struck down one attempted interpretive route. That distinction is central to India’s constitutional case: the Court found that the Constitution permitted Article 370 to be made inoperative, while insisting that the prescribed procedure could not be bypassed through an interpretation clause.

The five-judge bench decided In Re: Article 370 of the Constitution after a challenge to the orders issued in August 2019 and to the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act. Its legal conclusions support the Union’s position that the former state’s constitutional relationship with India could be changed through powers in the Constitution of India. They also show that judicial review remained available to test the means used. Supreme Court of India, judgment, 11 December 2023.

### The legal route—and its limits

On 5 August 2019, Presidential Order C.O. 272 applied all provisions of the Constitution of India to Jammu and Kashmir, with no modifications or exceptions. It also used Article 367, the Constitution’s interpretation provision, to change how the words “Constituent Assembly” in Article 370 were read. A subsequent declaration, C.O. 273, made Article 370 inoperative. Parliament also passed the Reorganisation Act, which took effect on 31 October 2019 and established the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir with a legislature and the Union Territory of Ladakh without one. Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019, India Code; Ministry of Home Affairs, J&K and Ladakh Affairs Division.

The Court separated the questions. It held that the President could apply the entire Constitution to Jammu and Kashmir under Article 370(1)(d), and upheld C.O. 272 to that extent. But it invalidated the part that used Article 367 to replace “Constituent Assembly” with “Legislative Assembly” in Article 370. An interpretation clause, the Court said, could not be used to amend Article 370 while avoiding that article’s own procedure. This was a meaningful limit on executive power, even though it did not undo the larger constitutional change.

The Court then upheld C.O. 273 under Article 370(3). It held that the President’s power under that clause did not disappear when Jammu and Kashmir’s Constituent Assembly dissolved in 1957. The absence of a recommendation from that former body therefore did not prevent the President from issuing a notification that Article 370 would cease to operate. The judgment also characterized Article 370 as a feature of asymmetric federalism, rather than a source of separate sovereignty. “Temporary,” in the Court’s analysis, did not mean that Article 370 expired automatically; it meant that the constitutional power to alter or end its operation continued to exist.

### Reorganisation and federalism

The Reorganisation Act raised a separate question. During President’s Rule, Parliament exercised the powers of Jammu and Kashmir’s legislature. Under Article 3, Parliament must seek the affected state legislature’s views before changing its area, boundaries or name. The Court held that these views are recommendatory, not binding, and upheld Parliament’s role in the 2019 process. It also upheld Ladakh’s separation as a Union Territory.

The judgment did not decide whether Parliament can convert an entire state into one or more Union Territories. The Union’s Solicitor General told the Court that Jammu and Kashmir’s statehood would be restored, and the Court left the broader Article 3 question open in light of that assurance. It directed the Election Commission to hold assembly elections by 30 September 2024 and said statehood should be restored “at the earliest and as soon as possible.” This qualification matters: the judgment settled the challenge to Article 370, but it did not erase the federalism question associated with a state losing statehood.

Critics had argued that the 2019 process placed too much power in the Union during President’s Rule and substituted Parliament for elected representatives at a moment when the state assembly was not sitting. Their concern is not answered merely by saying that the Court upheld the result. The Court’s distinction between what Article 3 permits and what it left open preserves a constitutional question for a future case. At the same time, its holding that state legislatures’ views under Article 3 are recommendatory reflects the text and prior interpretation of that provision, rather than a special rule created only for Jammu and Kashmir.

### What implementation still requires

The Election Commission conducted Jammu and Kashmir’s assembly election in three phases in September and October 2024, with final-phase polling on 1 October. The return of an elected assembly is a substantial democratic step, but it is not the same as restoration of statehood. As of 17 November 2026, the Ministry of Home Affairs still lists Jammu and Kashmir as a Union Territory with a legislature. Election Commission of India, election conclusion press note, 1 October 2024; Ministry of Home Affairs, J&K overview.

India’s constitutional case is strongest when it is stated precisely. The Supreme Court upheld the President’s use of Article 370(3), accepted the application of the full Constitution, and sustained the parliamentary process under Article 3. It also rejected the use of Article 367 to alter Article 370 indirectly, and left open whether a state can be converted entirely into Union Territories. That is not a contradiction; it is the Court defining the reach of different constitutional powers.

For India, the ruling establishes that constitutional integration can proceed through the mechanisms the Court found valid. For Jammu and Kashmir’s people, the task now includes accountable government, the protection of rights, and credible progress on the promised restoration of statehood. These obligations are not legal footnotes to the judgment. They are part of what will determine whether the constitutional settlement earns durable public confidence. A strong Union can defend national unity while respecting the federal principles and representative institutions that give that unity democratic legitimacy.

Sources