← All writing

ARTICLE 31·STRATEGIC AUTONOMY AND MAJOR-POWER RELATIONS

India–Canada Relations: Protecting Sovereignty While Managing Disputes

As of 17 November 2026

Original editorial illustration for article 31: India–Canada Relations: Protecting Sovereignty While Managing Disputes.
Original editorial illustration by Ibrahim Javaid. Conceptual scene, not to scale.

INTERACTIVE EXPLAINERStrategic autonomy and major-power relations

A closer look at the argument.

Open each layer to move from the article’s question, through its evidence, to the conclusion and limits.

01The question

As of 17 November 2026

Read the article and sources
02The record

India and Canada are rebuilding a relationship damaged by a dispute that touches the most basic obligations of government: protecting people from violence, respecting the sovereignty of other states, and applying the law through fair procedures. India is right to insist that threats to its territorial integrity and security be treated seriously. Canada is right to investigate…

Read the article and sources
03What follows

India should continue to press its concerns through official, verifiable exchanges and request action on specific threats. Canada should explain its claims to India through appropriate secure channels, protect communities from intimidation, and let its courts determine criminal responsibility. Both governments should reject collective blame and political rhetoric that…

Read the article and sources

As of 17 November 2026

India and Canada are rebuilding a relationship damaged by a dispute that touches the most basic obligations of government: protecting people from violence, respecting the sovereignty of other states, and applying the law through fair procedures. India is right to insist that threats to its territorial integrity and security be treated seriously. Canada is right to investigate credible threats on its own soil. Neither principle is sustainable if it is applied only when politically convenient.

India’s concern about separatist advocacy in Canada has a long history. The Canadian foreign-interference inquiry records India’s view that Canada has not taken its security concerns about Khalistan separatism seriously enough, and describes the clash between India’s security perspective and Canada’s protection of expression and association. That is a real policy disagreement, not proof that every supporter of separatism is violent. Canada’s intelligence service itself says that advocacy for Khalistan separatism is lawful political activity in Canada, while warning about possible coercion and transnational repression. The distinction matters: democratic states can protect peaceful speech while investigating specific criminal threats.

For India, a state’s duty to protect its citizens and constitutional order does not stop at its borders. New Delhi has reason to seek cooperation when it believes that individuals abroad are planning violence or using public platforms to incite it. The appropriate response is evidence-led cooperation: identify specific conduct, share material through lawful channels, and ask Canadian police and courts to act under Canadian law. Canada, in turn, should enforce its laws against credible threats and violence without confusing Sikh identity, peaceful activism, or criticism of India with criminality. The safety of Indian diplomats, visitors, students, and diaspora members must also be taken seriously.

The sharpest rupture followed the killing of Canadian citizen Hardeep Singh Nijjar in British Columbia in June 2023. In September that year, then Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told Parliament that Canada was pursuing “credible allegations” of a potential link between agents of the Indian government and the killing. In October 2024, Canada said the RCMP had identified six Indian diplomats as persons of interest in its investigation and expelled them; India withdrew six officials and expelled six Canadian diplomats, while rejecting Canada’s allegations and saying its diplomats’ safety was endangered. These are each government’s stated positions, not a settled account of responsibility. Canada also announced arrests of four people alleged to have been involved in the killing; arrests and allegations are not convictions. India has consistently denied involvement.

These claims cannot be resolved by louder public exchanges. The Hogue Commission’s final report summarized Canada’s credible-allegation position and noted India’s repeated denials. Its separate analysis also assessed India as a significant foreign-interference actor in Canada’s democratic processes. Those findings deserve serious attention. At the same time, the Commission’s mandate concerned interference in elections and democratic institutions; it was a public inquiry, not a criminal court deciding the Nijjar case. The Canadian Security Intelligence Service’s 2025 report further alleges coercive activity aimed at critics. India rejects Canadian allegations. Public reporting does not disclose all intelligence, and secrecy makes independent verification difficult. That uncertainty is a reason for disciplined investigation, not for treating allegations as proven—or dismissing them out of hand.

India’s sovereignty argument is strongest when it rests on universal rules. Canada cannot permit violence, intimidation, or covert direction of criminal acts within its territory. India cannot accept another government’s public allegation as a substitute for evidence and due process, or tolerate threats to its officials and citizens abroad. Diplomatic immunity is not an exemption from accountability; it is a framework for maintaining official channels while concerns are investigated. When either side believes that a diplomat has crossed the line, documented claims and proportionate procedures are more useful than retaliation that impairs consular work.

There is now a practical reason to preserve those channels. The two countries restored high commissioners in 2025 and resumed senior-level contacts. In March 2026, Prime Ministers Narendra Modi and Mark Carney issued a joint statement affirming respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, welcoming the return of diplomatic representatives and the gradual normalization of ties. Their June meeting supported continued security and consular dialogues; in October, the leaders welcomed a bilateral security dialogue and agreed to remain in contact ahead of Modi’s planned December visit. These steps do not settle the dispute. They create places to manage it.

The economic case is also substantial. Canada reports that two-way goods and services trade reached C$30.4 billion in 2025, including C$11 billion in goods; services trade is particularly linked to education. In March 2026 the leaders launched negotiations on a Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement, with a shared ambition to double trade to C$70 billion by 2030. They also welcomed a C$2.6-billion uranium supply agreement and cooperation on energy, critical minerals, research, and technology. These are not abstract gains: predictable ties support exporters, investment, universities, energy security, and jobs in both countries. India’s foreign ministry estimated nearly 393,000 Indian students in Canada at the end of 2024, illustrating the human stakes behind visa and consular arrangements.

The counterargument is that trade and diplomatic warmth must not mute security concerns. That is correct: commercial opportunity cannot buy silence about credible threats. But severing contact would make investigations, consular assistance, and clear communication harder. Engagement should be conditional on candour and accountability, not a declaration that the disagreement is over. Both sides can keep channels open while protecting evidence, judicial independence, and the safety of people.

India should continue to press its concerns through official, verifiable exchanges and request action on specific threats. Canada should explain its claims to India through appropriate secure channels, protect communities from intimidation, and let its courts determine criminal responsibility. Both governments should reject collective blame and political rhetoric that inflames tensions among Indians, Sikhs, or Canadians of any background. A durable partnership cannot be built on silence or accusation alone. It requires equal respect for sovereignty, credible evidence, lawful process, and steady diplomacy.

Sources